February 3, 2011
-
The Day the Music Died
Today is February 3rd. 52 years ago, three legendary musicians perished in an airplane crash en route to Fargo, North Dakota for another performance. Buddy Holly, Richie Valens, and J.P. “the Big Bopper” Richardson had just performed a show in Clear Lake, Iowa. Buddy Holly chartered the doomed airplane because another night in a tour bus without heat didn’t set well with Holly not to mention the fact that The Big Bopper was coming down with the flu and not to mention Carl Bunch, member of Holly’s backing band the Crickets, had a case of frostbite from exposure in the bus. The Crickets were Carl Bunch, Tommy Allsup, and Waylon Jennings. Walyon Jennings gave up his seat to the ailing Bopper and Richie Valens flipped a coin for the final seat aboard the four passenger plane. Richie won the ill-fated toss. Valens, Holly, Richardson and pilot Roger Peterson flew off into the night sky never to return. The plane crashed some 8 miles from the airport. Rumors exist as to the circumstances of the reason of the crash and will probably remain a mystery. Recently, the Big Bopper’s son has been petitioning to have the investigation of the plane crash re-opened because 2 months after the crash, a gun belonging to Buddy Holly was discovered in a cornfield. Richardson contends that the gun may have discharged and caused the plane to crash. Whatever the case may be, the fact remains that a great part of rock and roll died that day in 1959.

This is the memorial that has been erected on the site of the plane crash in Clear Lake, Iowa.
Buddy Holly(September 7, 1936- February 3, 1959) I believe that Buddy Holly did more for rock and roll than Elvis in those early years. Holly was the superior musician and song writer. He embodied a nature of rebellion. I think Elvis duplicated Holly’s attitudes after his untimely death. Buddy Holly was survived by his wife pregnant wife Maria Elena Holly. Soon after the crash, she miscarried due to the stress from Buddy’s death.

J.P. Richardson (October 24, 1930- February 3, 1959) The Big Bopper was survived by his wife Adrianne, 4 year old daughter Debra Joy and his son Jay Perry Richardson was born in April. The Bopper, at the time of his death, was building a recording studio in his home so that he could record his 20+ new songs with his friends as well as other musicians and be close to his family. Bopper was a well-loved figure in the early days of rock and roll and was a devoted family man.

Richie Valens( May 13, 1941- February 3, 1959). Richie was 17 at the time of his death. Valens had just made “La Bamba” a hit and also the first rock and roll hit to be in Spanish. Richie found an old guitar when he was five and even though it only had two strings he attempt to play it. His father restrung the guitar and encouraged his son to continue playing. Richie would take his guitar to junior and senior high to play for his friends on the bleachers before and after school. Richie was completely self taught at guitar and vocals. Richie recorded two albums in his short musical career. He will be remembered for such hits as “La Bamba”, “Ooh My Head”, “Come On Let’s Go”, “Framed”, and “Donna”. Valens was immortalized in the movie La Bamba. If you haven’t seen this movie, do so. Valens’ songs have been covered by many bands and will continue to be popular.
The crash of the Beechcraft Bonanza claimed three young rock stars. Their deaths have inspired one of the most popular rock songs to date. Don McLean recorded “American Pie” as a tribute to the three musicians. Even though Madonna butchered this song it will be best remembered for Buddy Holly, The Big Bopper and Richie Valens. Eddie Cochrane, who performed at the same show as the “Three” and rode the bus, recorded a song called “Three Stars”.


The three stars who perished were on a tour called The Winter Dance party and here is a website that contains all the dates along with pictures of the shows. It also includes the shows that were supposed to fall the show in Clear Lake, IA. Make sure you check out the photos of all those shows. I used to have them in this post but the website changed and I can’t link to them.I have to include some photos from the stop in Mankato simply because that venue is still in existence and out of all the venues on the Winter Dance Party it is the only one still remaining. Also, I went to college near Mankato so I saw posters around town from the Winter Dance Party show in Clear Lake and Mankato. Here’s an article from the Mankato Free Press from a few years ago.



Buddy Holly

The Big Bopper

Richie ValensI think that when rock stars are taken in an untimely fashion they will live on through the ages as is the case with Buddy Holly, The Big Bopper, and Richie Valens.
Comments (43)
It’s so sad that they died when they did. I remember being really young and learning about what happened to them and being sad.
@Shining_Garnet -
I remember watching the Buddy Holly movie with Gary Busey and being so sad and then relived it all with the Richie Valens movie which in my mind is one of the best biopics ever made. I cry most times I watch that movie.
This is well done and informative,I never heard the song Three Stars,thanks for including it.
That was a sad day for music,I remember when some of the band members from Lynyrd Skynyrd died,I loved that band.
GREAT post, M.! In honor of some great musicians!
I watched both movies…the one on Buddy and the one on Richie…two of my fav movies. I heard Don McLean in concert two years ago. He sang American Pie, of course. Got to talk to him after wards and get his autograph on my old American Pie album.
True Love Ways is my favorite Holly song.
HUGS!

Thanks for posting this. I got chills listening to Richie Valens sing La Bamba. That song is still popular with today’s kids, and it’s even in their beginning band books. I loved both the Buddy Holly and Richie Valens movies; need to watch them again. Maybe I’ll do that tomorrow on my third snow day.. American Pie has always been a favorite, and the story is so sad.
Thanks for remembering.
Thank you for posting this wonderful tribute. They just don’t make ‘em like that anymore.
This is a nice tribute to a local legend from these parts. I would like to make a correction if its not being rude. Buddy and the Crickets had split when this tour took place. Buddy had moved to New York and the Crickets who at that time consisted of J.I. Allison, Joe B Mauldin and Niki Sullivan. Buddy was signed to one label and his music was released as Buddy Holly. The Crickets were signed to another label and that music was released as The Crickets. Buddy was lead vocalist for the Crickets. There were legal problems had Buddy been mentioned on the Cricket music. Sonny Curtis, J. I and Larry Wellborn along with Buddy comprised the first addition of the Crickets. Niki dropped out to resume his education so on the Ed Sullivan show it was Buddy, JI and Joe B.
Sonny Curtis joined back with the band and my cousin Glen D. Hardin (who later became part of Elvis’s TCB band, EmmyLou Harris’s Hot Band among others} so in the mid 60′s the Crickets were Sonny, Glen, JI and Joe B the vocalist was Jerry Naylor. For a while another Lubbock Native David Box was the vocalist in the early 60′s, ironically he died in a charter plane crash in 1964 while on tour as a solo act. When his scheduling allows my cousin does some gigs with Sonny, JI and JB. In 1964 The Crickets with Jerry Naylor Sonny, JI, JB and Glen did a show at the Bull Barn here in Amarillo, after the show Sonny, Glen and Jerry all came to my parents house and stayed up all night talking. In 1994 The Crickets were on tour with Nanci Griffith, I lived in NY at the time so Glen gave me backstage passes at a show they did at the Hammerstein in NYC. They had dates in CT. RI, Boston and then the following Thursday Late Night with Davis Letterman, I went to that taping. Glen will be touring with Elvis the Concert, which will play three dates this month. Two Feb11th, Feb 12th at the Mohegan Sun and a one night only concert at Radio City Music Hall Feb 15th, They will tour Europe in 2012. I used to go to Norman Petty’s Studio in Clovis NM and watch the guys record.
Yep, that day changed rock ‘n roll forever. It was unheard of at the time for rock stars to die in plane crashes, so it was a big surprise to everyone when it happened. Sadly they wouldn’t be the last three rock stars killed in plane crashes.
On a semi-related note, I wonder what became of the Crickets. I know Waylon Jennings had a long and successful career as a country music star, but I wonder if Carl Bunch and Tommy Allsup ever had anymore success in the music industry or if they went on to do other things.
@Rob_of_the_Sky -
Though the handbill said Buddy Holly and The Crickets, Tommy and Waylon and Carl were not Crickets. My previous comment explains some of that
Too sad. I didn’t actually realize the last show was in Iowa.
I didn’t know Buddy’s wife was pregnant and lost the baby. That makes the whole thing that much more tragic.
I never realized that Tom Hanks looked quite so much like the Big Bopper. Huh. Chantilly Lace was always one of my favorite songs.
The bio-movie for Richie Valens was GREAT.
American Pie is another favorite song and a wonderful tribute to them. I’ve never heard Three Stars, though. Thanks for posting it.
Geez. Sad-making, but excellent post.
@TexasTidbits -
Thanks for the explanation. So how were Carl, Tommy, and Waylon involved with Buddy Holly during the Winter Dance Party tour?
@Rob_of_the_Sky -
The Crickets, Jerry, and Joe B had gone back to Lubbock. They still wanted to live in Texas. Tommy Allsup and Carl Bunch were studio musicians, Waylon was a radio dj, he was from Levelland and didn’t even know how to play bass until this tour started. But none of those three were ever Crickets. They didn’t even get to go back to Lubbock for Buddy’s funeral because they were the band for all the other acts on the winter tour. The Crickets still do some shows, Sonny Jerry and Joe B.and my cousin when he can. The Crickets are Joe, Sonny and Jerry Allison (Peggy Sue was Jerry’s wife. Other people that at one time played with the band so at the time they played with the other three they were honorary Crickets, those people are: Buddy Holly, David Box, Bobby Durham, Glen Hardin, Jerry Naylor, Niki Sullivan, Earl Sinks, Ben Streed and Albert Lee. Albert Lee replaced my cousin Glen D. when Glen joined Elvis’s TCB Band.
@adamswomanlost -
The Buddy Holly Story was so inaccurate that Buddy’s family would not give script approval that is why the “band” members in that movie were called Jessie Charles and Ray Bob. None of the Crickets went to the premier and Sonny Curtis plays a song he wrote called the Music Didn’t Die and it is a slam against the movie.
@adamswomanlost -
The Real Buddy Holly Story- Sonny Curtis http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3wPJXCxxfgQ
The other day you asked (on another blog) what happened to all the good music. Lots of it died along with Holly, Valens and the Bopper.
(The rest is on oldies radio. The stuff that’s popular now only wishes it was music.)
@TexasTidbits -
Thanks for the link, W.! I never knew about any of this!
I went to memorial show for these three last year. The Big Bopper’s son played him. It was really great!! I’ve always loved Buddy Holly’s music. My grandma and I used to dance around to it when I was a kid.
Man, what a sad loss.
I can’t rec some blog sites when I’m at work for some reason. I’ll try to remember to rec when I get home.
really cool blog, very comprehensive study!
@seedsower -
I didn’t know about that song “Three Stars” until after the first time I posted this, one the 50th anniversary. It’s hard to listen to because you can hear the pain in his voice.
I’m trying to think of musical acts that have died while I’ve been alive that impacted me and the only one I can think of is Kurt Cobain. I know Tupac and Biggie Smalls died but I wasn’t impacted by their deaths.
@adamswomanlost -
That’s awesome that you got to see Don McLean. When I was a freshman in high school I bought a Don McLean cd just for the American Pie song. we used to play it all the time. I also remember one night the school dean came into my dorm room and listened to it. That was very awkward. One of these days I’m going to go down to the crash site.
I had to download that song. My favorite has become “Dearest” but I didn’t know it until I saw Juno. Before that I really loved “Peggy Sue”, “All My Loving”, and “Every Day”.
@musicmom60 -
I need to see the Buddy Holly movies again. I need to order it through my library or at least check to see if it’s in their system.
that’s great to hear that bands are keeping their work relevant. I heard a pep band play something by Buddy Holly but I can’t remember now.
@jamekablue -
No they don’t
@TexasTidbits -
I guess I’m wrong then.
@Rob_of_the_Sky -
I read this awesome book about all the deaths in rock-n-roll called Take a Walk on the Darkside. The creepiest thing I’ve ever read is about the 27 club.
@ItIsAllGravy -
I need to get down to the crash site. Last year I had the directions and was ready to go but life got in the way. Of course I didn’t know about those directions. They had me swimming across the Mississippi.
I love La Bamba. It’s been years since I’ve seen it.
@Automaton_Emotion -
Yeah that part of the story was so hard for me when I first heard it.
I remember having Chantilly Lace on a cassette tape and listening to it over and over again because I thought it was the funniest thing ever because he was talking to someone and you couldn’t hear it and I wanted to know what she was saying to get him to react that way.
What’s sad to me is that American Pie is such a great song and great tribute but so many young people will only associate the term with a guy who screws pies.
@ZombieMom_Speaks -
Yeah, so much music died in such tragic ways.
@kinseydanielle -
Yeah when I was looking for photos of the Big Bopper I kept finding them of his son. They look so much alike.
@godfatherofgreenbay -
I’ve been to some stuff honoring Buddy in TX, but going to the crash site would be something I’d like to do. Just to stand there and think about them and honor them…a way to say “thank you for how your music as touched my life.”
@Unstoppable_Inner_Strength -
Yeah, it’s hard to compare it to anything because rock music was in it’s infancy and some of the pioneers died. I wonder what would have happened had the plane not crashed. I get the feeling that they would probably be headlining shows in Las Vegas.
Thanks for coming back for the rec.
@godfatherofgreenbay - Seriously. I HATED that movie series. I understand the point of sophomoric humor, but that was just one, long awkward moment after another. It was literally painful to watch.
@Diva_Jyoti_3 -
Thank you
@NightlyDreams -
I need to find it on dvd. I love it and like I’ve said it makes me cry. He was 17. He was so popular and then dead at 17.
@adamswomanlost -
I did post one photo of a memorial and there is another on the property featuring a huge pair of Buddy’s style of glasses.
@Automaton_Emotion -
There are times when I enjoy the American Pie movies. I have to be in a mood for them but the one that always gets me is the wedding one. It had a great story but some of the hijinx were just horrible. Also I have not seen a single one of the American Pie movies that are technically part of the series even yet don’t have any of the main characters. I’ve heard there is another one in the works.
Does Netflix have any of these movies? I haven’t checked, but might be worth a look.
Thanks for posting this reminder of this very sad day. So very tragic.
@musicmom60 -
Yeah I really should sign up for netflix
@gottobereal64 -
thank you for stopping by and reading
@godfatherofgreenbay -
yeah it is definitely a tragedy. his music lives on though.